Cubs BCB After Dark: Would you take back Aroldis Chapman?
· Yahoo Sports
Welcome back to BCB After Dark: the hippest hangout for night owls, early risers, new parents and Cubs fans abroad. Come on in out of the heat. There’s lot of cool in here. There’s no cover charge. We still have a few tables available. The hostess will seat you now. Bring your own beverage.
BCB After Dark is the place for you to talk baseball, music, movies, or anything else you need to get off your chest, as long as it is within the rules of the site. The late-nighters are encouraged to get the party started, but everyone else is invited to join in as you wake up the next morning and into the afternoon.
Visit betsport.cv for more information.
Last night, I asked you who was the current best reliever in the injury-plagued Cubs bullpen. About 40 percent of you pick Ryan Rolison, which is either pretty impressive or pretty sad, considering that he was in waivers hell this past winter. This past off-season, Rolison was a member of the Rockies, Braves, White Sox and Cubs. Come to think of it, it’s pretty impressive what Rolison has done and it’s pretty sad that the Cubs don’t have Daniel Palencia or some other truly great reliever at the moment.
On Tuesday nights, I don’t do any movie stuff. But I can always find time for jazz. You can skip ahead if you want.
Tonight we are honored to feature saxophonist Kenny Garrett and his Quintet in Amsterdam in February of 2020. So just before the pandemic shut the world down. Garrett is joined by Corcoran Holt on bass, Vernell Brown Jr. on piano, Rudy Bird is the percussionist and the drummer is Samuel Laviso.
This is “Sing a Song of Song.”
Welcome back to everyone who skips the music.
As noted yesterday, the Cubs bullpen has been held together with scotch tape and string this year. Closer Daniel Palencia has hit the injured list twice. Joining him on the 15-day injured list are Ethan Roberts (forearm), Phil Maton (knee) and Hoby Milner (appendix). The 60-day IL is even more crowded with Hunter Harvey (triceps), Porter Hodge (Tommy John) and Riley Martin (left flexor strain). Hodge is definitely out for the year and Harvey and Martin haven’t even made the first steps towards returning yet. Then there is Shelby Miller, whom the Cubs signed coming off of Tommy John surgery and they knew was highly unlikely to pitch this season. So Miller doesn’t count.
My point is, for all the concentration on the injuries to the starting rotation, the bullpen has been banged up just as badly. As an aside, I think Craig Counsell has accomplished an almost impossible task of keeping this team not just in the hunt, but a strong favorite to make the playoffs despite all the injuries to the pitching staff. Counsell has earned his salary this year.
So while the Cubs are almost certain to try to add another starting pitcher by the trade deadline, they’re also likely to add to the bullpen. The best reliever likely to be on the market is someone Cubs fans are already familiar with: Red Sox left-hander Aroldis Chapman.
I don’t need to remind you of the almost superhuman heroics that Chapman performed throughout the 2016 playoffs and World Series. Manager Joe Maddon rode him like a rented mule (because, metaphorically, he was a magnificent rented mule) in the World Series and it was clear that by Game 7, Chapman was out of gas. He gave up that home run to Rajai Davis that none of us will forget. In fairness to him, Davis hit a good pitch. But Chapman stayed in the game and gutted out the ninth inning, despite clearly being exhausted. Whether it was luck, fate or Chapman’s willpower, he got through the ninth inning. The Cubs won it in the tenth and Aroldis Chapman is the only pitcher in the history of the Cubs to have a Game 7 win.
That was ten years ago. Now Chapman is ten years older at 38. His fastball doesn’t average 100 miles per hour anymore. The four-seamer is “only” 97 these days. However, when Chapman was last a Cub, he was mostly a fastball/slider pitcher. These days, Chapman has added a sinker, which comes in at 98 and which has become his primary and best pitch. He throws it even more than his four-seamer. He still has the slider, but that is now a third offering. His changeup is now his fourth pitch. After several years of being just a decent relief pitcher, Chapman is back to being elite.
This year with the Red Sox, Chapman has made 26 appearances for 24.1 innings. He’s 0-3 with a 2.19 ERA and has converted 16 of 18 save appearances. Chapman has struck out 32 batters and walked 12. That’s a K% of 30.2 and a BB% of 11.3. Opposing hitters are batting an anemic .204 off of him.
So it’s clear that Chapman would be a big upgrade to the bullpen. What would it take for the Cubs to acquire him from the Red Sox? Chapman is a free agent at the end of the year and the good news is that the days of giving up a Top 100 prospect like Gleyber Torres for a two-month rental of a reliever are likely over. So not Jaxon Wiggins, Josiah Hartshorn, Owen Ayers or anyone like that. Probably not Matt Shaw either, unless the Red Sox want to toss in Sonny Gray. (And probably not even then, since the Cubs kind of need Shaw this year.) But I do think it would probably cost two good prospects, one of which would have to be a top ten Cubs prospect. So getting Chapman would hurt. However, one reason a team builds up a good farm system is to trade some of it away for current major leaguers.
Then there is the other elephant in the room, which is something the Cubs dealt with back in 2016: Chapman’s 2015 arrest and 30 game suspension for domestic violence. The criminal charges against Chapman for that incident were dropped, but domestic violence advocates will tell you that is common no matter what the circumstances.
I can’t tell you how you should feel about that. I strongly believe that domestic violence is a serious issue that needs to have more serious consequences. I can tell you that I didn’t feel good cheering for Chapman in 2016, even though I obviously wanted him to succeed. But if you don’t want Chapman on the Cubs because of that, I don’t blame you. I might even agree with you.
However, I also believe in second chances and redemption when it is warranted. I believe people can change. Has Chapman earned a second chance? I can’t say I’ve followed his career closely enough to say one way or the other. I do know that there hasn’t been another domestic violence incident in the last decade speaks to Chapman having changed. Except that we have to put a “that we know about” qualifier in there.
So tonight’s question is “Should the Cubs try to trade for Aroldis Chapman?”
Thank you for stopping by. We always like to see a friendly face. Please get home safely. Call a ride if you need one. Recycle any cans and bottles. Tip your waitstaff. And join us again next time for more BCB After Dark.